glacier logo   Debating Glacial Theory, 1841
Project Profile || Background || GoogleEarth Tour || Episodes || Bibliography   

William Buckland WILLIAM BUCKLAND
English

Following Cuvier, you argued for a relatively recent geological "revolution" – a unique break with the past just prior to the "present order of things" – for which you found evidence in various cave deposits and fossils. However, you later converted to an alternative explanation – the glacial theory – following a visit to the Alps and a tour of Scotland with Louis Agassiz.

On GoogleEarth Tour pay particular attention to:

  • Reliquiae Diluvianae
  • +? Alps?
  • +? Glen Roy?

Familiarize yourself with the following Episodes:

  • Paris
  • Vindiciae Geologicae - Reliquiae Diluvianae
  • 1840 Visit to Britain

Read and summarize:

  • Appendix to Vindiciae Geologicae (p.38 of the pdf file)
  • Reliquae Diluvianae, Part 2
  • "On the evidences of glaciers in Scotland and the north of England" (Part 1)

Be aware:

  • There is nothing wrong with having abandoned the diluvial camp in favor of glaciation (in fact it is perhaps entirely to your credit): but your colleague and friend Lyell is not entirely convinced and this might influence you in favor of some "hybrid" theory.